A federal judge has granted Coinbase’s appeal request in the SEC lawsuit, pausing proceedings to address whether crypto transactions require investment contracts to be classified as securities. The ruling comes at a pivotal time for crypto regulation.
On January 7, 2025, just ahead of the inauguration of the first pro-crypto US president, District Judge Katherine Polk Failla made a significant decision in the ongoing US SEC vs Coinbase Global Inc. (NASDAQ: COIN) case. The judge granted Coinbase’s request to appeal a key legal question to a higher court. Additionally, Judge Failla paused further proceedings in the case until the appeals court can determine a crucial issue: whether cryptocurrency transactions require an actual investment contract to be considered securities.
“We appreciate the Court’s careful consideration. On to the Second Circuit we go,” Paul Grewal, the Chief Legal Officer at Coinbase, noted.
The ruling is crucial for the cryptocurrency industry amid the upcoming helm change in the SEC. Moreover, Paul Atkins, the nominated SEC Chair by President-elect Donald Trump, is expected to mostly drop the crypto cases left by his predecessors.
According to Katherine Minarik, the CLO at Uniswap Labs, the court’s ruling recognizes that the SEC’s approach to crypto assets and web3 companies is messy. Furthermore, the US SEC has been using obsolete securities laws to govern and manipulate the nascent cryptocurrency technology.
“The court’s opinion rightly recognizes that the SEC’s ecosystem theory is messy and that district courts continue to land in different places on how to apply Howey to crypto, so it sure would be nice for an appeals court to weigh in,” Katherine noted.
Facts About the SEC vs Coinbase Case
The US SEC filed a lawsuit against Coinbase Global in 2023 alleging that the crypto exchange has been facilitating unlawful trading of at least 13 digital assets, which ought to be registered as securities. In March 2024, Judge Failla allowed the SEC’s lawsuit claims to proceed against Coinbase apart from the allegations connected with the exchange’s wallet.
The US SEC accused Coinbase of operating against the securities law despite approaching its bid to go public. In addition, the agency knew the nature of Coinbase’s operations before giving the firm the green light to go public.
Coinbase has been arguing that the crypto tokens traded on its platform should not be classified as securities due to a lack of sufficient legal oversight. Moreover, the US SEC has not received the necessary regulatory approval from Congress to reign over the cryptocurrency industry.
Bigger Picture
The cryptocurrency industry is positioning itself strategically as the Trump administration prepares to take office, having pledged to implement more comprehensive and industry-friendly regulations. A potential victory for Coinbase in this landmark case, combined with the anticipated regulatory reforms, could mark a decisive turning point for digital asset adoption.
This shift toward clearer oversight would likely boost market confidence, potentially attracting heavyweight institutional investors such as pension funds and investment banks that have historically remained on the sidelines due to regulatory uncertainty.
next