BlackRock’s proposal for in-kind redemption on its spot Bitcoin ETF product is now under review
By Godfrey Benjamin
Edited by Marco T. Lanz
Updated
3 mins read
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is now evaluating a proposal from BlackRock Inc (NYSE: BLK) that could transform the way Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) operate. According to The Block, the asset manager wants to shift to in-kind redemptions.
This move aims to streamline transactions for institutional investors, reducing friction and costs associated with cash-based transactions. This modification could set a new industry standard and push Bitcoin further into mainstream financial markets if approved.
Last month, on behalf of BlackRock, Nasdaq filed an amendment that would permit in-kind redemptions for its iShares Bitcoin Trust. This change lets authorized participants (AP) receive Bitcoin directly instead of cash.
The SEC formally acknowledged the proposal in a Thursday filing, inviting public commentary within 21 days of its publication in the Federal Register. From there, the regulator will decide to approve, reject, or further scrutinize the plan.
Shifting from cash to in-kind redemptions could significantly enhance liquidity, lower transaction costs, and reduce taxable events. This would make it an attractive alternative for institutional players navigating the Bitcoin market.
While individual investors will not be directly impacted, the broader implications for Bitcoin ETFs could be substantial.
Notably, the regulatory agency initially resisted in-kind redemptions. When spot Bitcoin ETFs were first introduced, the SEC favored a cash redemption model. It argued that it provided greater oversight and mitigated risks associated with Bitcoin’s volatility.
This model required ETF issuers like BlackRock to liquidate Bitcoin, distribute cash to investors, and reallocate assets accordingly. However, after approving multiple Bitcoin ETFs in January 2024, the conversation around in-kind redemptions reignited.
Proponents say this approach makes Bitcoin ETFs more like traditional commodity ETFs. They argue that in-kind transactions improve efficiency.
If BlackRock’s proposal gets the green light, it could open the floodgates for other ETF issuers to adopt similar structures. In-kind redemptions would let APs swap ETF shares for Bitcoin, boosting market liquidity.
This could also ease downward pressure from forced Bitcoin sales in cash redemptions. Bloomberg Senior ETF Analyst James Seyffart emphasized that retail investors cannot participate in these transactions.
However, institutional investors would benefit from the increased flexibility and efficiency. The move could also drive more traditional financial institutions to engage with Bitcoin ETFs. It could further help the asset class gain more acceptance in mainstream finance.
BlackRock’s proposed shift to in-kind redemptions comes when the broader Bitcoin ETF market evolves rapidly. In August 2023, Coinspeaker reported that Grayscale Investments won a major legal battle against the SEC.
The court ruled that the SEC must reconsider its decision to block Grayscale’s plan to convert its Bitcoin Trust into a spot ETF. This victory played a pivotal role in the eventual approval of multiple spot Bitcoin ETFs in January 2024,
The development shows the shifting regulatory landscape surrounding Bitcoin in traditional finance. The SEC’s willingness to engage with in-kind redemptions shows a softer stance toward Bitcoin-based financial products. This shift is expected considering the pro-crypto Donald Trump administration.
Disclaimer: Coinspeaker is committed to providing unbiased and transparent reporting. This article aims to deliver accurate and timely information but should not be taken as financial or investment advice. Since market conditions can change rapidly, we encourage you to verify information on your own and consult with a professional before making any decisions based on this content.
Benjamin Godfrey is a blockchain enthusiast and journalist who relishes writing about the real life applications of blockchain technology and innovations to drive general acceptance and worldwide integration of the emerging technology. His desire to educate people about cryptocurrencies inspires his contributions to renowned blockchain media and sites.
